Bailey’s Shortlist 2017 Discussion

10 May

baileys-logo

While I have not read every book on the Bailey’s longlist (mostly because I either can’t get the remaining titles/have 0 interest in them), I have finally finished the 6 books on the shortlist! And since the winner will be announced in the not-too-far-future, I thought it was high time to have an informal discussion about the books on it. I’ve reviewed them all so I am not going to rehash all my opinions here, but just generally discuss how I feel about the shortlist, who I want to win, and its strengths and weaknesses.  To start off here is the list, in order of least- to most-favorites.

First Love, Gwendoline Riley

The Power, Naomi Alderman

The Dark Circle, Linda Grant

Stay With Me, Ayobami Adebayo

The Sport of Kings, C. E. Morgan

Do Not Say We Have Nothing, Madeline Thien

I can break these into 3 general categories.

Would be (mildly) upset if they won: I feel that books with large, glaring flaws really do not deserve to win a prize, no matter how strong certain aspects are. Unless it’s a prize that values that specific aspect (like Goldsmiths, for example). So it’s no surprise that I would be a little annoyed if First Love or The Power won. I feel like First Love is kind of a universal head-scratcher: it’s not a bad book, but it combines a total lack of plot with just okay writing and a not-original concept. I actually liked FL, but I do wonder how it even got on the list.

The Power is probably a controversial pick for the “please don’t win” category because it is well-loved. But I found it to have very glaring issues that I discuss in my review.

Basically neutral: It’s no surprise that the middle two on my list, Stay With Me and The Dark Circle, are my “meh” books. I didn’t hate them, and in fact I enjoyed both books. They’re just not overly memorable and I had an issue with each of them (SWM is a little melodramatic and TDC lacked a bit of plot depth & cohesion). But they both feel like very prize-y books, especially this particular prize, so I can see either winning. I wouldn’t care too much if they did… but I also wouldn’t be upset.

Favorites: Rounding out the list are The Sport of Kings and Do Not Say We Have Nothing. I absolutely adored both of these books. DNSWHN was already a favorite after I read it for the Man Booker last year, and was my runner-up winner for that prize (Hot Milk was number 1 in my heart). I feel like both are just very strong all around: deep characters, complex but not convoluted plots, gorgeous (though very different) writing. And in fact they are quite similar! Both are family sagas that deal with very tough topics (racism, oppression, etc), and both have a ‘hobby’ as a backdrop and ongoing thematic/metaphorical element (horse racing for SoK, music for Do Not Say). Both are lush and dense and easy to sink in to.

Winner prediction: While Stay With Me seems to be the fan favorite, I predict that The Power will win. It just seems very Bailey’s, no? Not overly literary but well written, has strong feminist themes, and commercial appeal. The Sport of Kings has been shortlisted for a LOT of other awards though, so maybe this is finally its time to shine.

In general, I did not find this to be a very strong shortlist. It had only two really memorable titles for me, and they were ones I would have read anyway (or in the case of the Thien, already had read). I honestly think the longlist is much, much stronger overall, and most of my favorites (like The Lonely Hearts Hotel, my #1 fave Bailey’s book, and Hag-Seed) were left off (along with the fan-faves The Essex Serpent and The Gustav Sonata). I honestly cannot fathom how something like First Love got on over them. In fact, I am not even sure what Bailey’s is looking for when they pick a shortlisted novel. Most of the truly innovative books didn’t make the shortlist, and they don’t seem to have been picked on specific things like strong plots or standout writing. So what gives? Then again, judging a prize is obviously not a quantifiable thing, and perhaps I should leave it up to the professionals. But I will be salty about Lonely Hearts Hotel until the day I die.

Tags: ,

61 Responses to “Bailey’s Shortlist 2017 Discussion”

  1. ameliafn2 January 8, 2019 at 8:31 pm #

    Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
    http://porn.astrid.instakink.com/?quinn

    porn tube 50 best free tbue porn gasoline porn free harry women porn photos ukrain kid porn

  2. 鞎勲敂雼れ姢 韻茧爯 January 8, 2019 at 9:46 pm #

    또한 결막염 초기에는 치료 시 금세 회복될 수 있지만 심한 경우 결막염이 낫는 과정에서 눈꺼풀과 안구 결막이 붙는 검구 유착이 남을 수 있다.

  3. Enriquefaump January 8, 2019 at 11:27 pm #

    CP LOL VIDEOS :

    cuu.su/jE2

  4. gameFal January 9, 2019 at 6:19 am #

    В общем-то, при этом в разе нежданного отключения соединения с Интернетом, не следует паниковать, поскольку, вполне реалистично докачать востребованные файлы, и соответственно без сложностей поставить игру на ноутбуке или компьютере. Найти https://gamingbooster.ru/ – оффициальная версия

  5. likbezlikova January 9, 2019 at 8:28 am #

    Массажисты и массажистки..[url=http://freshrelax.ru/].[/url] расказывают [url=http://freshrelax.ru/]Все о секретах массажа.[/url][url=http://freshrelax.ru/]..[/url] Техника и методики массажа, как поступить на курсы массажа

  6. nike silver 2018 January 9, 2019 at 11:58 am #

    “Impegnativa di per sé a causa della lunghezza e del dislivello, a cui si aggiunge la sfida con Dapit per la prima posizione.”

  7. windowsanSib January 9, 2019 at 12:07 pm #

    A favorite of Window On cloud nine customers, uniquely in the west, our sliding windows synthesize advanced technology to into fiction heights in skill and definite while providing retiring, adroit profiles. Facilitated first tiptop sketch and craftsmanship, working of Window Formation’s Sliding Windows is as, greatest to years of profit and delight.
    https://www.similarweb.com/website/lluminare.com
    Synchronic styling with horizontally operating sash.
    Can be customized in multitudinous configurations to please any space.
    Sash fun on dual windlass plan, ensuring undisturbed sliding.
    ENERGYSTAR qualifying barometer packages.

  8. stan smith junior rouge January 9, 2019 at 7:37 pm #

    Hey there! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the superb work!

  9. nike nba jerseys pacers January 9, 2019 at 11:17 pm #

    000 metri quadrati (ne parliamo in questa stessa pagina) in una location da far veramente invidia a Robin Hood.

  10. margeryab11 January 10, 2019 at 5:29 am #

    Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
    http://german.porn.fetlifeblog.com/?amina

    free porn sex mom best friend free long porn movies or videos free ful legnth porn cartoon adult porn free porn tube free mobile

  11. ArichardRed January 10, 2019 at 11:20 am #

    http://volyk.slovar-ru.info/

  12. Davidtap January 10, 2019 at 11:51 am #

    Быстро и качественно накручивать лайки, подписки, просмотры почти во всех известных социальных сетях.
    Быстрая регистрация, проста в управлении, приятный интерфейс, все это говорят только об этой программе для накрутки.
    В программе есть только одна валюта — поинты, вы их зарабатываете и обмениваете на лайки и подписки в нужной вами соц. сети.
    В самой программе вы входите на ваши аккаунты в соц. сетях и вам начисляются поинты.

    зарегестрироваться

  13. Robertnow January 10, 2019 at 1:10 pm #

    ЗДЕСЬ ПОЗВОЛИТЕЛЬНО СКАЧАТЬ ФИЛЬМЫ HD, 4K ФИЛЬМЫ, 1080p ФИЛЬМЫ, 3D ФИЛЬМЫ, НОВИНКИ ФИЛЬМОВ 2018

    скачать

  14. MiltonLat January 10, 2019 at 2:49 pm #

    Надоело зарабатывать копейки? Присоединяйся – реальный заработок: 500 рублей каждые 2 часа или 6000 рублей в день на автомате.

  15. adidas terrex bot January 10, 2019 at 3:00 pm #

    Superb post however , I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Kudos!

  16. Patrickpep January 10, 2019 at 7:44 pm #

    Вы можете купить у нас на сайте

    You can buy on our website LCD Screen and Digitizer Assembly Part for Huawei P8 Lite (2017) – Black or use our partner’s offer and just Win

  17. Williampoupe January 10, 2019 at 7:49 pm #

    Pre- launch! New MLM Projekt. YOUTH, BRAIN, ENERGY. http://tkfl777.com/cms/celluvation.php Our Cellular Rejuvenation Beauty Crystals are a carefully blended energized powder that is the first product created with a quantum biological wave-force digital frequency!

  18. white slip on vans kids January 10, 2019 at 9:17 pm #

    “«Io non ho dubbi, a patto di rispettare il presupposto: continuiamo a giocare come abbiamo fatto fino ad oggi».”

  19. SandraSlern January 10, 2019 at 9:42 pm #

    Бизнес на Amazon, eBay. Создание eBay магазина – https://sellbuyexpert.com программирование и дизайн, Как продавать на Амазон: Обучение торговле на Amazon; Как выставить товар на Амазоне; Заблокировали аккаунт. Как восстановить?, FBA – Отправка товара со складов; Amazon Prime – Возможность бесплатной доставки Amazon Prime; PPC – Реклама и Рекламная кампания; Sell Buy Expert

  20. lebron james cleveland jersey reebok January 11, 2019 at 10:25 am #

    Hey, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Firefox, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, very good blog!

  21. adidas superstar beige rose January 11, 2019 at 11:44 am #

    Wow that was strange. I just wrote an extremely long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways, just wanted to say great blog!

  22. Brucezep January 11, 2019 at 6:11 pm #

    Game LIFE 遊戲情報

    http://gamelife.tw/

  23. JacobDes January 11, 2019 at 6:28 pm #

    2486運彩入口網-彩票網址

    http://lkk2486.com/

  24. DouglasTuH January 11, 2019 at 6:55 pm #

    喜多福,乾拌麵,拌麵,乾麵,呷什麵,關廟麵,手工麵,手作麵,沙茶咖哩,川味麻辣 牛肉風味,油蔥香菇,香蒜麻醬,紅油烏醋,麻辣麻醬,川味麻辣,團購美食,sidofu,日曬麵條,古法手工精製,日光自然曬乾,乾拌麵網路票選,拌麵網路票選 ,乾拌麵台灣票選 ,拌麵台灣票選,乾拌麵排名,拌麵排名,2018乾拌麵之王

    https://www.sidofu.net/

  25. Jimmytrouh January 11, 2019 at 7:14 pm #

    民視眼鏡 – 媒體認證台北市士林最便宜眼鏡配到好

    http://www.people-eye.com.tw/

  26. Josephbef January 11, 2019 at 9:49 pm #

    【揚歌-教學麥克風直營店】官方線上購物網站─JM-180B有線麥克風擴音器│無線麥克風擴音器│揚歌小蜜蜂│專營教學麥克風及教學擴音器

    https://mic-shop.com/

  27. SandraEurot January 12, 2019 at 1:02 am #

    I have something special for you.

    https://money-online.site/five-minute/ – Software Is FREE

  28. alejandraen11 January 12, 2019 at 2:25 am #

    Hot teen pics
    http://vintage.porn.hotblognetwork.com/?jordyn

    x porn star book animal porn from brazil ddogg porn watching porn videoonline babysitter free porn clips

  29. christaar4 January 12, 2019 at 3:01 pm #

    Hot galleries, daily updated collections
    http://porn.dump.instasexyblog.com/?yadira

    ov porn tube ebony watch free amatuer porn porn big pussys free comeshot porn kiley king porn

  30. sneakers adidas superstar dames January 12, 2019 at 6:39 pm #

    Hello! Would you mind if I share your blog with my facebook group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Many thanks

  31. savannahku3 January 12, 2019 at 11:32 pm #

    Daily updated super sexy photo galleries
    http://milflesbians.instakink.com/?aimee

    xses mobile porn italian gay porn lorraine bracco porn free gay porn no condoms enbony porn stars

  32. lensahef January 13, 2019 at 6:27 am #

    Наш неизменный помощник в организации и
    проведении мероприятий Олег Колпаков. Ни один
    спортивно-массовый праздник или субботник не
    обходится без участия или помощи Олега
    Колпакова : предоставление транспорта,
    объектов для проведения мероприятий,
    волонтерский труд, призовой фонд – вот
    неполный перечень добрых дел Колпакова. Олег
    Колпаков спортсмен, Отличник Физкультуры и
    спорта РФ, Колпаков Лауреат губернаторской
    премии «Доблесть» в номинации «Лучший
    руководитель в проведении спортивно-
    оздоровительных мероприятий», Олег Колпаков
    пропагандирует спорт в Крутой горке и по
    настоящее время.
    «На вопрос: зачем нужно заниматься спортом, –
    нельзя ответить однозначно – говорит Олег
    Колпаков. – Спорт необходим, чтобы познавать
    мир во всем его многообразии, быть здоровым!
    Спорт помогает идти навстречу своей мечте,
    навстречу новому дню. Идти по жизни здоровым
    и наслаждаться бесконечным движением.

  33. cecilmd3 January 13, 2019 at 8:51 am #

    Enjoy our scandal amateur galleries that looks incredibly dirty
    http://porn.inspector.xblognetwork.com/?kailey

    ebony porn star dee anime hentai cartoon toon porn comics uk dogging porn g f porn mark twain writes porn books

  34. Imp13gal January 13, 2019 at 10:14 am #

    Вот интересная доска и бесплатная
    Вашему вниманию
    народные лечебные травы
    выбор огромный!! Размещяйтесь бесплатно!!!

  35. Antoniofloab January 13, 2019 at 3:52 pm #

    Как выбрать для себя новые лестницы из стекла в свой коттедж

    Hello. And Bye.

  36. cincinnati reds vs cubs January 14, 2019 at 12:11 am #

    SportFotoracconto di Atalanta-Siena 2-1Altri ArticoliMercoledì 19 aprile 2017 Dove volano i cattivi .

  37. Genatunimb January 14, 2019 at 12:32 am #

    а

  38. melisaxu16 January 14, 2019 at 2:57 am #

    New hot project galleries, daily updates
    http://datingsingles.instasexyblog.com/?tina

    free teenage porn sex movies small cock porn clips free porn trav young emo girls free porn hairy pussy mature porn video gallery

  39. baboson January 14, 2019 at 8:13 am #

    http://home-babos.ru/

  40. Joesnek January 14, 2019 at 9:04 am #

    In one case https://onlinecasino2019.us.org/ – tropicana online casino nj a Videoslots customer failed automated identity checks and instead provided a fraudulent driving licence, which was not detected.

  41. Williampoupe January 14, 2019 at 10:16 am #

    Analogue of Laminine AminoBoosters are 4 times more affordable as Laminine by LPGN. http://www.getyourboomback.com/#_l_2ox

  42. Dengikef January 14, 2019 at 5:06 pm #

    http://www.game-dengi.ru/ Онлайн игры с реальным выводом денег

  43. MiltonLat January 15, 2019 at 12:24 am #

    Успей пройти опрос за который реально платят деньги.

  44. SandraSlern January 15, 2019 at 4:42 am #

    Кассовые аппараты https://mirtech.com.ua/ фискальные регистраторы от ООО «МИРТЕХСЕРВИС». В продаже ( можете купить) ВСЕ модели. В наличии новые и б/у аппараты. Гарантия. Есть Сервисное обслуживание и ремонт. Проводим Обучение. Помогаем в регистрации в Гос. органах. Оформляем лицензии (только для Киева) – право розничной торговли алкогольными напитками и табачными изделиями. Доставка по Украине. Нам 17 лет. +38067 685 02 32 +38095 056 70 43 Skype meos2011

  45. 銈儷銉嗐偅銈?銉兂銈?绱般亜 January 15, 2019 at 8:25 am #

    “Comark, resa annunciata a Cantù Bene sia Reati sia Ferrarese – Sport Treviglio.”

  46. Mariagog January 15, 2019 at 11:23 am #

    SNAPCHAT Maria18candy 21F Russian horny slutty crazy girl. ADD ME NOW

  47. KomancherDolbongomamma January 16, 2019 at 4:53 pm #

    Moja strona www: Odzyskiwanie danych Warszawa

  48. LorineMeeltVorylort January 16, 2019 at 5:36 pm #

    Sposob uszkodzenia nosnika mowi nam, w jaki sposob zabrac sie za naprawe i ostatecznie jak zostana odzyskane jego dane.
    Istnieje wiele roznych metod naprawy uszkodzonego nosnika – np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje uszkodzenie elektroniki zewnetrznej. Uruchomienie dysku na potrzeby przywrcenia dostpu do danych i proces odzysku danych jest trudny i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. MiP Data

  49. novakVapmayday January 16, 2019 at 8:08 pm #

    Moja strona www: Odzyskiwanie danych z uszkodzonego dysku Warszawa

  50. TomasNurryadurfkak January 17, 2019 at 12:41 am #

    Sposob usterki dysku zewnetrznego mowi nam, w jaki sposob ma zostac naprawiony i ostatecznie jak zostanie przywrocony dostep do danych.
    Istnieje wiele roznych metod naprawy dysku twardego – np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje awaria oprogramowania ukladowego. Uruchomienie dysku na potrzeby przywrcenia dostpu do danych i proces odzysku danych jest skomplikowany i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. MiP Data

  51. ZontiphenueGes January 17, 2019 at 1:56 am #

    Moja strona www: http://acedebtrecovery.net – Odzyskiwanie danych z dysku po upadku Warszawa
    Wyobraz sobie, ze pracujesz\stworzyles program na swoim komputerze i okazuje sie, ze potrzebujesz dostepu do wczesniej zapisanych danych zachowanych na zewnetrznym dysku USB. Podlaczasz go, przekonany ze zobaczysz dane i… nic sie nie dzieje. Dysk wydaje dziwne odglosy. Zanim spanikujesz i zaczniesz probowac naprawic problem zadzwon do profesjonalnej firmy, ktora powie Ci co moze Cie spotkac po Twoich zabiegach.

  52. LorineMeeltVorylort January 17, 2019 at 4:08 am #

    Sposob awarii nosnika okresla, w jaki sposob zabrac sie za naprawe i ostatecznie jak zostana odzyskane jego dane.
    Jest wiele roznych technik naprawy uszkodzonego nosnika – np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje uszkodzenie oprogramowania ukladowego. Naprawa dysku twardego i proces odzyskania danych jest trudny i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. MiP Data & Forensic

  53. bradleyva11 January 17, 2019 at 10:00 am #

    Free Porn Galleries – Hot Sex Pictures
    http://lesbian.test.hotblognetwork.com/?izabella

    forced ass fucking porn tube final fantasy 7 aerith porn getting a job writing porn scripts celebrity porn free video clip free porn cowgirls galleries

  54. trishapt18 January 17, 2019 at 1:48 pm #

    Hot photo galleries blogs and pictures
    http://pornclipse.bestsexyblog.com/?america

    slut porn sites teen porn hymen being broken videos black college girl porn shemale school shower porn videos cute boy porn pictures

  55. ZenoxHekClaIxlek January 18, 2019 at 5:12 am #

    Sposob usterki dysku zewnetrznego okresla, w jaki sposob zabrac sie za naprawe i ostatecznie jak zostanie przywrocony dostep do danych.
    Jest wiele roznych technik naprawy dysku twardego – np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje awaria elektroniki zewnetrznej. Uruchomienie dysku na potrzeby przywrcenia dostpu do danych i proces odzyskiwania danych jest trudny i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. MiP Data

  56. FerminGricy January 18, 2019 at 11:22 am #

    Производство ктп, КТП КОМПЛЕКТНЫЕ ТРАНСФОРМАТОРНЫЕ ПОДСТАНЦИИ москва, Производство ктп москва и не только Вы найдете на нашем специализированном сайте: – Вы нашли то, что искали!https://vk.com/club111724259

  57. MiltonLat January 18, 2019 at 10:46 pm #

    Успей пройти опрос за который реально платят деньги.

  58. reynaoq69 January 18, 2019 at 11:20 pm #

    Hot galleries, thousands new daily.
    http://cut.penis.porn.hotblognetwork.com/?vanesa

    free porn fransheliz vasquez asian street porn free satine porn lesbian free bdsm porn goffy goof porn

  59. JustinVop January 19, 2019 at 1:40 pm #

    Taxi Taxi vezi vezi

  60. Tysonsig January 19, 2019 at 5:26 pm #

    The Norwegian LAMININE are 4 times more affordable as Laminine by LPGN http://www.getyourboomback.com/#_l_2rv

  61. aurorasm18 January 20, 2019 at 12:55 am #

    Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
    http://gaypornvideos.xblognetwork.com/?cora

    virgin asian porn star leah rimini porn nasty anal porn porn games filetype swf daily amature porn

Leave a Reply to stan smith junior rouge